Rob Law Max Recruitment: Proud to be supporting club rugby in Wellington in 2014
ClubRugby Home Wellington Story
Auckland Auckland Canterbury Hawke's Bay North Harbour Taranaki Wellington

Aisle be back: The Pumas and the Lions

Representative Rugby | 13 September 2017 | Kevin McCarthy

Aisle be back: The Pumas and the Lions

Beauden Barrett runs out on to his home track in New Plymouth against the Pumas on Saturday. Photo by Dave Lintott Photography. More photos here

Now this is a column of a Hurricanes fan, so stating the obvious, I won't be joining the ranks of the Beaudy haters.

And boy have they starting coming out of the woodwork this season.

Indeed, you would think that really, if we'd just had a different first-five, we'd have nailed the Lions series.

And we'd be leading the Rugby Championship by now. Oh hold on, we are leading the Rugby Championship.

Then there's the ill-discipline. Indeed, with Beaudy off the park on Saturday, the All Blacks suddenly screamed back into control. Further evidence.

As for SBW, who is playing horribly - good thing we milked him back into the test side so quickly - he only has Beaudy to blame. Terrible passing.

Tick the same box with Aaron Smith. Beaudy only excels with the extra time that Smith delivers.

Now for this narrative to really work,  it is important to set aside the line breaks, and the matchwinning  try in Dunedin.


Then you've got a pretty good case for dropping Beaudy. Oddly enough the criticism often is couched in terms of "he's brilliant, but . . . ".

So let's get a grip. The  All Blacks aren't playing well. Beaudy isn't playing that well. The rush defence is a thing, and a thing yet to be combatted.

But the Rugby Championship 2017 will be utterly forgotten come RWC 2019. Sure it's nice to win, but the relevanceof the tournament is only in what it contributes to learning for the future.

As some have suggested, in fact the team has suggested, they are a bit like lab rats, being asked to find ways to problem solve the fact other sides are closing the gap.

At the speed the game evolves tactically, the rush defence could be well obsolete in two years' time. If it isn't then it really is time to worry.

So be patient and if you feel your Beaudy bile rising, just think that sabotaging the confidence of our first-five is precisely what opposing coaches would love to see.

Vladimir Putin would admire the handiwork.


Lab rats or not, rejoice at the Springbok resurgence. They're back with a bit of swagger and a ton of confidence.

Whether it's real or not, we'll find out. But a cocky bokkie is just what every All Black fan should want.

There's was something pitiful about the way the Boks dragged themselves from miserable defeat to miserable defeat over the last couple of seasons.

Now, let's hope, a win over South Africa can be restored to what it should be. Something to savour.

A loss? Well, we just don't want to think of that do we. 


It's probably too much to hope for a home team boilover against Caterbury this Sunday, although the red and blacks are turning around after a midweek match. 

The Dompost is doing its best to talk down Wellington's prospects, which is a realistic assessment. 

That did however work a charm against the last premiership team to waltz into town - Taranaki. So we can hope. 

Certainly the Lions have got off to a flier, and but for the nailbiter loss against Tasman, would be four from four. They seem to be doing many more things right than wrong this season, so fingers crossed they don't lose momentum with their toughest opposition of the year. 

Lifelong All Blacks supporter Kev has followed the Hurricanes since they began. Last year his faith in them was rewarded when they won the title – they've missed out in 2017, but he'll be back!

Latest Stories
Gains and Losses 2019
Steven White, 19 Mar 2019
School leavers to watch 2019
Adam Julian, 19 Mar 2019
Norths win 2019 National Club Sevens
Steven White, 12 Feb 2019
Support Our Partners
LesMills Jan2019
Advertise with Club Rugby
College RugbyAmateur Sports Association
Rugby Heartland New Zealand
Chainsaw Photos
© 2005-2017 Club Rugby | About | Contact | Coach Login